Thursday, June 20, 2024

Book Review: We Were Never Here

I read Andrea Bartz's We Were Never Here for my May book club meeting. An endorsement on the front cover, by bestselling author Megan Miranda, bills it as "Incredibly tense and atmospheric; a sharp, unsettling thriller about power, obsession, and the inescapable grip of the past." This psychological mind-trip was intense. I described the book to my youngest son, saying it isn't my usual fare (not that I'm against thrillers - I love a wild ride - but haven't been in the mood for intense). Then, I added, "They'll probably make it into a movie, so you won't have to read the book."

We Were Never Here is about best friends Emily and Kristen, who take backpacking trips to foreign countries. Compulsively readable, the book spins a tale of trauma that tests the bonds of trust and friendship. A sexual assault during their travels the previous year left Emily deeply disturbed. Kristen had interrupted the assault and killed the assailant. Fearful of foreign justice systems, they hid the body. The book opens with their current trip to Chile. Kristen takes a man back to the room and Emily leaves her time and space. Yet when she returns to their shared room, she finds Kristen has killed a second time to foil an assault. Once again they dispose of the body.

When Emily returns to her home in Wisconsin, the only person she can talk to about this traumatic event is Kristen. But they must be careful. Moreover, Kristen is acting like nothing happened at all. Emily questions how well she really knows her best friend. Will their heavy secret keep Emily from developing her relationship with her boyfriend, Aaron? Why is Kristen stalking Emily and her friends?

I do expect this to be made into a movie. Yet, the Netflix plans never got off the ground. It would make for a very engaging drama with lots of psychological tension and plenty of twists and turns. If only they could make the movie without overexposure during the sex scenes. The book handled them discreetly, focused primarily on the women's feelings of danger. The assaults serve as springboards for the psychological games that follow.

2 comments:

Gretchen said...


Good review, gotta pass on this book. (too intense for the moment) FYI: We're on a long road trip, driving to Alaska and most of the time internet has been inaccessible.

Wendy Hill said...

Gretchen - Safe travels to you. Enjoy time in the beauty of nature and with family. Worth giving up internet accessibility, no doubt.