Book Review: The Undercover Book List

The Undercover Book List, by Colleen Nelson, is like a tween version of The Reading List (reviewed here). Similarities abound. Both books highlight two unlikely individuals brought together by reading and a list. Both books reveal the chasm left behind in a father's absence. An aspect of anonymity drives both plot lines. Characters face family issues. Plus, each offers the reader a host of book suggestions and discussions.

Jane's best friend, Sienna, moves away and leaves her an opportunity to find a new best friend based on their shared passion for books. She initiates what she calls "the undercover book list," a secret correspondence carried out in the pages of their favorite book. Through this series of anonymous notes, X and Y recommend books to each other as their friendship blossoms. While Y knows who X is, X is in the dark. Will X be disappointed when she discovers the true identity of Y? Can Y fill the hole left by Sienna in Jane's life and in Jane's book quiz team?

Colleen Nelson understands middle school students. From her outstanding development of the misunderstood prankster to the intense ache Jane experiences missing her father, Nelson crafts tween characters that are sure to resonate with the intended audience. Thankfully, the book holds equal appeal for grown-ups who might read the book alongside their tweens. Yet another brilliant book stimulating further reading recommendation. This would make an outstanding classroom read-aloud!